Top 5 Common Mistakes in CST Interviews and How to Avoid Them

Most lost marks at the CST interview are avoidable.

Contents

Most lost marks at the CST interview are avoidable. These are the five mistakes we see most, with a fix for each.

1. Rehearsing the wrong interview

The 2027 interview is two 15-minute online stations. Management and Clinical: one management scenario and two clinical scenarios, five minutes each. Portfolio: a three-minute presentation, two minutes of questions on it, two five-minute questions on your evidence. Score out of 100: portfolio 45, management and clinical 45, MSRA 10.

Fix: time every scenario to five minutes and the presentation to three, and practise answering questions about your own evidence without notes.

2. Answering the management scenario as a clinician

It is set in a clinical place and marked on probity, professional integrity, awareness of safety and ethics; judgement under pressure and prioritisation; and communication. Five minutes on a differential earns nothing.

Fix: name the problem (an error, an unsafe colleague, consent, confidentiality), make the patient safe, say what you would do and who you would involve, and why.

3. Never saying what comes first, or who you would call

Judgement under pressure and prioritisation is marked on every management and clinical question. “I would escalate” scores nothing on its own. The panel wants what you would do first and why, what can wait, and which senior you would contact, when, with what.

Fix: a practice partner who asks “what first?” and “who exactly?” after every answer, until you say it unprompted.

4. Treating the portfolio station as a formality

It is worth 45 of the 100 points, and whole domains score zero for a missing index page, more than one item per domain, patient-identifiable information, a missing GMC number or an editable signature box. Only the first item in each domain is assessed. Evidence goes up between 19 and 24 February 2027; no upload, no interview. The two questions come from the Patients, Partnership and Communication domain and the Colleagues, Culture and Safety domain, and over-claiming can be tested in them.

Fix: one clean PDF per domain, index page on top, strongest item first, nothing you cannot defend for five minutes. Rehearse the presentation method before the topic arrives with your invitation from 16 February 2027.

5. Getting the day, and the week after, wrong

Log in ten minutes early on Qpercom with photo ID, alone, ready to show the whole room, and do not record. If the panel cannot see you, the interview can be stopped. Afterwards, preferences go on Oriel between 8 and 22 March 2027 (dates may change), initial offers come by 6 April 2027, and you have 48 hours to answer one. Feedback and scoresheets follow later.

Fix: test connection, camera and microphone the day before, keep a charged backup device, and put the Oriel dates in your calendar.

Prepare with Medset

The Medset CST Interview Course has clinical and management scenarios with answer frameworks and guidance on the presentation. The mock interview option adds timed mock stations with personal feedback.

Checked against NHS England’s Core Surgery Interviews, Applying, Recruitment timelines and Portfolio Guidance pages, November 2026. Dates are NHS England’s and may change.

Picture of Leo Gundle
Leo Gundle
Leo is a widely published and internationally prize-winning Plastic Surgery Registrar at Guys’ and St Thomas’ Hospital, London. He has a passion for teaching, mentoring, and career development.
Teach The Teacher: Elevate Your Professional Growth

In the ever-evolving world of education, continuous professional growth for teachers is essential. The innovative “Teach The Teacher” programme focuses on peer-to-peer learning, allowing experienced educators to share their expertise