The 2027 CST interview has two stations: one management scenario and two clinical scenarios, then a presentation and two questions on your portfolio evidence. “Tell me about a time when…” questions turn up inside that structure, as follow-ups and above all in the portfolio questions, which are about things you have done.
Where they appear
- The portfolio station. Two five-minute questions on two of your domains, Patients, Partnership and Communication and Colleagues, Culture and Safety, chosen by the assessors. They ask what you did, why, and what came of it, for your audit, teaching, presentations and publications.
- Follow-ups in the Management and Clinical station. After a scenario answer, a panel member may ask whether you have faced something similar.
- Questions on your presentation. Two minutes, usually about your own part in what you presented.
NHS England publishes no sample questions. It does publish the marking: for the management question, probity and professional integrity, safety and ethics, judgement under pressure and prioritisation, and communication; for the portfolio questions, your skills and knowledge; communication throughout.
Why they carry weight
The person specification asks for teamwork, leadership, working under pressure, knowing your limits, honesty about your achievements, and commitment to audit, teaching and patient safety. A question about something you did is the fastest test of all of those. It also tests probity: over-claiming in your portfolio is taken extremely seriously, and these questions are where it gets probed.
STAR, with one line added
Situation in two sentences. Task: what you had to do. Action: what you did, in the first person. Result: what happened, with a number where you have one. Then one line of Reflection: what you would change, or what it changed. Aim for two minutes inside a five-minute question and leave room for follow-up.
Build examples from what you uploaded
The assessors have read your evidence, and only the first item in each domain counts, so those items are your examples. For each, prepare a STAR answer and the obvious follow-ups: your own contribution, what you would do differently, what changed for patients or colleagues.
Questions worth practising
These are not official. They match the person specification and the two portfolio domains.
- Tell me about the audit or quality improvement project you uploaded. The standard, the finding, what changed after the second cycle, your part.
- Tell me about teaching you designed or delivered. The gap, what you delivered, the feedback, what you would change.
- Describe a decision you made under pressure. What came first, who you called, what you learned.
- Describe a time something went wrong, or nearly did. What you did, who you told, what changed.
- Describe working with a difficult colleague or a struggling team. What you did, how it ended.
Four habits
- Real examples with real numbers. Anything you claim can be tested.
- “I”, not “we”. The panel is scoring you.
- Pick examples that show the person specification: safety, teamwork, leadership, honesty, commitment to surgery.
- Practise out loud and timed, with someone who interrupts. Record one run and listen back.
Prepare with Medset
The Medset CST Interview Course covers the management and clinical scenarios and the presentation, with answer frameworks for each. The mock interview option adds a full mock with personal feedback.
Checked against NHS England’s Core Surgery Interviews, Applying and Portfolio Guidance pages, November 2026.